How Big is the Wealth Effect? Decomposing the Response of Consumption to House Prices

Aruoba, S. Boragan; Elul, Ronel; Kalemli-Özcan, Ṣebnem

doi:10.21799/frbp.wp.2019.06

Working Paper

How Big is the Wealth Effect? Decomposing the Response of Consumption to House Prices

Abstract: We investigate the effect of declining house prices on household consumption behavior during 2006-2009. We use an individual-level dataset that has detailed information on borrower characteristics, mortgages and credit risk. Proxying consumption by individual-level auto loan originations, we decompose the effect of declining house prices on consumption into three main channels: wealth effect, household financial constraints, and bank health. We find a negligible wealth effect. Tightening householdlevel financial constraints can explain 40-45 percent of the response of consumption to declining house prices. Deteriorating bank health leads to reduced credit supply both to households and firms. Our dataset allows us to estimate the effect of this on households as 20-25 percent of the consumption response. The remaining 35 percent is a general equilibrium effect that works via a decline in employment as a result of either lower credit supply to firms or the feedback from lower consumer demand. Our estimate of a negligible wealth effect is robust to accounting for the endogeneity of house prices and unemployment. The contribution of tightening household financial constraints goes down to 35 percent, whereas declining bank credit supply to households captures about half of the overall consumption response, once we account for endogeneity.

Keywords: Financial crisis; mortgage; individual-level data; general equilibrium; bank health; credit supply;

JEL Classification: E32; O16;

https://doi.org/10.21799/frbp.wp.2019.06