Home About Latest Browse RSS Advanced Search

Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
Working Papers
Is Bigger Necessarily Better in Community Banking?
Joseph P. Hughes
Julapa Jagtiani
Loretta J. Mester

SIPERSEDED BY WP 18-11 We investigate the relative performance of publicly traded community banks (those with assets less than $10 billion) versus larger banks (those with assets between $10 billion and $50 billion). A body of research has shown that community banks have potential advantages in relationship lending compared with large banks, although newer research suggests that these advantages may be shrinking. In addition, the burdens placed on community banks by the regulatory reforms mandated by the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act and the need to increase investment in technology, both of which have fixed-cost components, may have disproportionately raised community banks’ costs. We find that, on average, large banks financially outperform community banks as a group and are more efficient at credit-risk assessment and monitoring. But within the community bank segment, larger community banks outperform smaller community banks. Our findings, taken as a whole, suggest that there are incentives for small banks to grow larger to exploit scale economies and to achieve other scale-related benefits in terms of credit-risk monitoring. In addition, we find that small business lending is an important factor in the better performance of large community banks compared with small community banks. Thus, concern that small business lending would be adversely affected if small community banks find it beneficial to increase their scale is not supported by our results.

Download Full text
Cite this item
Joseph P. Hughes & Julapa Jagtiani & Loretta J. Mester, Is Bigger Necessarily Better in Community Banking?, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, Working Papers 16-15, 10 Jun 2016, revised 13 Mar 2018.
More from this series
JEL Classification:
Subject headings:
Keywords: Community Banking; Scale; Financial Performance; Small Business Lending
DOI: doi.org/10.21799/frbp.wp.2018.22
For corrections, contact Beth Paul ()
Fed-in-Print is the central catalog of publications within the Federal Reserve System. It is managed and hosted by the Economic Research Division, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Privacy Legal